The Red Queen by Philippa Gregory – Book Review

4851894122 c5b11d0919 m pictureThe Red Queen by Philippa Gregory
Published by Touchstone, an imprint of Simon & Schuster

One of the only heirs of the Lancaster line of the royal family, Margaret Beauford is a very important young girl, but still a powerless one. She is utterly convinced that she has a vocation and desperately wants to be a nun. As a young lady with royal blood in a time when the king is childless and perhaps slightly crazy, Margaret is not to have the luxury of choosing her own fate and going into a convent. Instead, she is expected to breed, to produce a son for the Lancaster line. Not only that, neither she nor her family have any say in who she is to marry. At twelve she is wedded to King Henry VI’s half-brother, the twenty-something Edmund Tudor. At thirteen, days after the death of her husband, Margaret gives birth to a son, Henry Tudor, and has a vision that he will one day be King of England. Suddenly, Margaret has a new vocation from God: seeing her son crowned.

Gregory’s “The Other Boleyn Girl” is the novel that brought me to historical fiction in college, but much of her work after that went downhill, in my opinion. In fact, I disliked “The Other Queen,” so much (after purchasing it in hardcover), that I nearly swore her off completely. I’m glad I decided to give her another chance with her new series, The Cousin’s War. I thought that the first book in the series, “The White Queen,” was perhaps her best book since “The Other Boleyn Girl.”

“The Red Queen,” I think, is even better. Gregory still suffers from a bit of the repetitiveness that she showcased in “The White Queen,” but I think it came off better, and flowed more naturally in this book. Yes, Margaret did express her belief in her religious vocation ad nauseum in the beginning of the book in particular, but she was a very head strong young preteen and teenager, so it fit with her character. In fact, she was obnoxiously headstrong and self-righteous throughout the entire book. The fact that Gregory kept me enjoying “The Red Queen” as much as I enjoyed “The White Queen” with its much more sympathetic protagonist is what makes me say that this is actually the stronger book.

If you gave up on Gregory after some of her weaker Tudor books, try her Cousin’s War series. You can really start with either “The White Queen” or “The Red Queen,” but I recommend that you give it a try.

Buy this book from:
Powells.*
A local independent bookstore via Indiebound
.*
Amazon
.*

This review was done with a book received from the publisher.
* These links are all affiliate links. If you buy your book here I’ll make a very small amount of money that goes towards hosting, giveaways, etc.

28 comments to The Red Queen by Philippa Gregory – Book Review

  • I really enjoy Philippa and like you it was The Other Boleyn Girl that made me really start to crave historical fiction. I have not read the red or the White Queen yet but I can not wait to do so!

  • Oh, good! I’m just starting this book now and I’m happy to see that you liked it even better than The White Queen. I’m not sure why, but I’m a little nervous about this one (which makes absolutely no sense since it’s just a book – and I’ve not liked PG’s work before and survived – The Virgin’s Lover).

  • I definitely have to agree that so far THE WHITE QUEEN is PG’s best work since TOBG (of those I’ve read, at least: all her Tudor Court books w the exception of THE QUEEN’S FOOL). I bought it at a PG author event when it first came out, but didn’t actually read it until a few weeks ago while on vacation. The reason I waited so long was because I really, really disliked THE OTHER QUEEN and so was in no rush to read her next one.

    THE WHITE QUEEN has restored my faith in her as an author, and THE RED QUEEN is turning out to be equally as good (I’ll have my final verdict by tomorrow). Either way, The Cousin’s War is shaping up to be a very good series.

  • Pam

    Oh I love Philippa Gregory. I read The Other Boleyn Girl while living in London and then proceeded to buy and read all of her books every last one and then visit the places she touched on with her words on my mind. For being able to do that Gregory will always be one of my favorites. I think upon it as one of the most fascinating literary experiences of my life. Being able to go while reading to the places and read the book there!

    White Queen and Red Queen are the only two I haven’t gotten to. I am glad you liked it, now I know I will.

  • Sounds like an enjoyable read and I keep hearing good things about her books so one of these days I will have to give them a try. As a side comment, the cover is great.

  • I really enjoyed this one as well. I was surprised how much I disliked Margaret, yet how much I enjoyed the book.

  • I’m going to read the White Queen for sure now, so that I can read this one!

  • I feel like the token historical fiction/PG idiot here. I need to just decide at some future point to spend an entire month reading the best ones. I will come to you when that day happens.

  • I’m so glad you enjoyed this one! I am going to be reading it this week and I still hesitate before picking up a new Philippa Gregory book. Knowing that you enjoyed it makes me feel less apprehensive.

  • Jen-Girls Gone Reading

    Glad to see that Philippa Gregory can still write a good historical fiction book. I was starting to get nervous and jump off her bandwagon. This one “might” make me come back…

  • I”m going to read this one soon – it seems like most people are liking it. I hated The Other Queen but rather enjoyed The White Queen, so I’m looking forward to this one.

  • I’ve never read any of Gregory’s work, but a good friend of mine keeps urging me to give it a try. Sounds like I need to.

  • I am one of those who has fallen off the PG bandwagon. I am not sure yet whether I am going to climb back on or not.

  • I had The White Queen on my bookshelf and while I was still trying to find the time to read it, my sister decided she was going to read it. And so she took the book and I haven’t seen it since. I’m guessing that I need to get it back and read it.

  • Amy

    For as much as I like historical fiction, I’m going to pass on this one. I read The White Queen and was disappointed by it. I don’t know why but I’m not a fan of her writing.

  • I still haven’t read The White Queen (Other Queen put me off her books for a while) but really enjoyed this one. Despite the repetitiveness, Margaret seemed like a product of her time. I loved the ending scene with Elizabeth of York, too.

  • Wow. I used to love Gregory. I loved The Other Boleyn Girl and The Queen’s Fool. But then The Boleyn Inheritance happened. And I had the misfortunate to read Zelda’s Cut, which I found to be truly horrible. I haven’t looked back since. However, you review of this book makes me wonder if I shouldn’t give her another try. TOBG was such a favorite of mine… thanks for the review!

    • Skip everything else she wrote on the Tudors (“The Other Queen” is truly horrible), and pick up these ‘Cousins War’ series books, they’re much more up to the standards of TOBG.

  • I loved the Other Boleyn Girl and then was disappointed by others. I have both the White and the Red Queen to read — you’ve given me hope.

  • I loved The White Queen and I can’t wait to read this! I’m jealous that you have it already.
    Like you, I loved The Other Boleyn Girl but totally went off Gregory after reading one of her subsequent books, The Queen’s Fool. I think this new Cousin’s War series is fantastic though so I’m glad I gave her another chance.

  • Rebecca

    I love Phillipa’s writing and the fact that its like I get transported to that time. The Other Queen was a little disappointing, but I think the trick is to read them in order. I’m reading the Red Queen at the moment.

  • deanne

    I liked all of her books on tudor history except The other Queen it was horrible. The Boelyn Inheritance and the The Vigins Lover were not the best reads but they were still good. However The White Queen was my favorite so I will def. pick up a copy of the Red Queen.

  • GravitonX

    My wife was pleasantly surprised and intrigued when I brought “The Red Queen” home from the book store. As someone who doesn’t typically read fiction or even historical fiction, I was thoroughly absorbed by the book. I found the view into feudal England fascinating and the narration engaging. I read it every chance I could get. I’m looking forward to picking up some of Ms. Gregory’s other books. She definitely has a new fan.

  • Suzane

    I’m very surprised by the criticism. I have read every historical fiction I can find, and am always impressed with the research and flavor of Ms. Gregory’s novels. With the exception of the Wideacre novels. Then again, I am one of the few people who thought that the Twilight series was fluffy garbage. If anyone can write a novel better than Phillipa Gregory, please do so, I look forward to rating your efforts.

  • helen mc hugh

    i just finished reading “the white queen” and really enjoyed it. i have read several of gregory’s books, and loved everyone of them. they are intriguing.

Sound Bytes Monthly Link-Up