The Heart is Not a Size by Beth Kephart – Book Review

The Heart is Not a Size by Beth Kephart

When Georgia sees a notice on the corkboard at the grocery store about a summer trip to Anapra in Juarez, Mexico, she knows immediately that she needs to go.  The first step is to convince her best friend Riley to go, the next to convince her parents to let her go. Promising to spend the rest of her summer corralling her younger brother Kevin should do it, though. Georgia and Riley really need this escape from the ordinary; Georgia has panic attacks and Riley’s mother dismisses her as ‘average.’ Something seems particularly wrong with Riley, actually, she is disappearing almost before Georgia’s eyes. Although Ampara was a bit of a whim initially, it will end up touching the girls in a very special way.

Beth Kephart’s writing is, as always, gorgeous. There was a lot in this novel: eating disorders, panic attacks, poverty, invisible people, rape and murder and disappearances. One thing that was particularly interesting to me was that Georgia was supposed to be somewhat heavy – her friendship with the much smaller Riley being the origin of the title – but either the reader doesn’t get any hint of this until at least a third of the way through the book or I totally missed it until that point. I appreciated that, this wasn’t a ‘fat girl’ book, but a book about the live of a girl who just happened to be somewhat overweight, but whose weight is not her main attribute.

I sort of wish “The Heart is Not a Size” had been about twice as long as it was. So much really wasn’t explored as much as I would have liked: Georgia’s weight, her panic attacks, the lives of the people in Juarez and Anapra, the muertas, and more. However, none of those things was really the point of this book, and that’s okay. As with the other of Kephart’s books I read, “The Heart is Not a Size” was really about a regular girl finding irregular strength to deal with the difficulties that arise in her life.

I don’t think I liked “The Heart is Not a Size” quite as much as I liked “Nothing But Ghosts,” but that’s a little like saying I don’t like chocolate quite as well as chocolate mixed with peanut butter; both are fantastic, one is just ever so slightly more fantastic than the other. If you haven’t read anything by Kephart yet, you really need to get on it ASAP – she’s not just for the young adult audience, but for everyone who likes lyrical writing and thoughtful stories.

Buy this book from:
A local independent bookstore via Indiebound

This review was done with a book received from a friend.
* These links are all affiliate links. If you buy your book here I’ll make a very small amount of money that goes towards hosting, giveaways, etc.

Digiprove sealCopyright protected by Digiprove © 2010

9 comments to The Heart is Not a Size by Beth Kephart – Book Review

  • That would be me you are speaking to! With all of you such avid Beth-ites, I’m almost embarassed to admit I haven’t read her yet. I’ll make sure I start with Nothing But Ghosts.

  • I’m glad you liked it, even if it wasn’t your favorite kind of chocolate. 😉

  • I’m so glad to see this lives up to my high expectations of Beth’s work.

  • I haven’t read any of Kephart’s book yet – I really should start. I’ve been reading such really lovely reviews of her work.

  • Glad to hear you liked this one. :)

  • I can’t wait to read this. I sooooo loved Nothing but Ghosts.

  • Liz

    I haven’t read Kephart yet, either, but I’ve seen too many rave reviews to ignore her too much longer! Sounds like “Ghosts” is one to start with. My own daughter recently picked up a book she’s really enjoying (she’s very finicky, so I was so pleased) — a book of YA suspense (and romance), called “Her Mother’s Diary” by David Curry Kahn. A teen’s on the run from drug lords, and finds unlikely haven in the form of an elderly man mourning the reeling from the loss of his wife. She reaches out to him, and finds strength to overcome her own problems and help others as well. Good story, good messages.

  • Ha, analogies with food, chocolate in particular, are fabulous. I am particularly excited to hunt down Beth at BEA.