The Girl Who Would Speak for the Dead by Paul Elwork – Book Review

The Girl Who Would Speak for the Dead by Paul Elwork
Published by Amy Einhorn Books/Putnam, an imprint of Penguin

In the long, slow days during the summer of 1925, Emily Stewart discovered what to a thirteen year old is an amazing talent: she can crack her ankle in such a way as to throw the sound, a talent best put to use in her twin brother Michael’s room in the middle of the night. Michael, unlike Emily, sees a purpose for this parlor trick beyond making things go bump in the night, and so he gathers a group of local children, telling them stories of the family’s cousin Regina, who died decades earlier as a young girl on the property and pretending that Emily can summon and converse with her, with Regina answering in knocks. News of Emily’s alleged talent quickly spreads, and soon reaches local adults. In a time when the wounds of World War I still lay so heavy on American hearts – particularly the wounds caused by young men who failed to return – the belief that Emily can speak for the dead catches on much more quickly and with far more people than she could have even imagined.

The Girl Who Would Speak for the Dead is interesting not only as a tale of spiritualism in the early parts of the 2oth century and how it took hold, but also as a story of how seemingly harmless events can get out of hand so quickly. Emily’s spirit knockings started first as an innocent trick on her brother, then as a slightly less innocent trick on the somewhat obnoxious boy who liked to follow around after Michael. Before she knew it, she was adding other spirits to her repertoire, beyond simply Regina. Some of the spirits were her and Michael’s concoctions, but sometimes she was feigning to speak for people’s actual lost loved ones, and it was not too long before she felt that she was in over her head. As for the spiritualism, Elwork’s novel laid out quite clearly how and why it would have been so easy for people in the 20s to get caught up in such things, I don’t think I’ve ever fully taken into account the impact World War I had on the national psyche in this area – incidentally, I think I am somewhat more sensitive to it than I would otherwise have been, being as I am in the middle of the Maisie Dobbs series by Jacqueline Winspear, which deals with life in England between the wars.

Elwork has written a very interesting novel that has left me with many things to ponder about human nature – particularly when grief is endemic – and the way the world works. The connection between grieving and spiritualism is one I now want to continue to explore in other books, and I hope to see more, similarly thought-provoking novels from Elwork in the future.


Buy this book from:

Source: Publisher.
* These links are all affiliate links. If you buy your book here I’ll make a very small amount of money that goes towards hosting, giveaways, etc.
Digiprove sealCopyright protected by Digiprove © 2011

9 comments to The Girl Who Would Speak for the Dead by Paul Elwork – Book Review

  • It’s such a study in the human psyche, when so many young men die or are missing…no closure for the loved ones. I can completely see how people would be desperate enough to believe anything. This sounds like a really compelling book.

  • Great review! This is the second positive review I’ve read today. And with a Maisie Dobbs mention I’m all in for sure.

  • Pam

    Ah, the mention os Maisie, has my interest since I’m about to start her latest. I didn’t think it would be my sort of thing but it has been a great ride. Maybe when I’m done with her final addition and missing the time period and crime period, I’ll dig into this. Thanks for the review! ;O)

  • Between you and Julie, I want to read this one right now!

  • Every time I read something or even see this book, I want to read it all the more. Thanks for the review and the nudge in the right direction.

  • I’m glad you liked it. Interesting, isn’t it, how sympathetic and yet horrifying Emily is – she knows what she is doing is wrong and her remorse at doing so is palpable, and yet…how do you say no? Does the guilt she feels about conning grief-stricken families weigh more than the consequences when the truth comes to light? So many questions…

    • And I think at first it was really just all in fun, then by the time she realized it was not all fun anymore, she was in so deep that she was afraid of the consequences for herself AND the people she was tricking if she stopped going along with it.

  • I just received this one from Library Thing this week – your review has me intrigued! I’m planning to read it in the second half of April.

  • Interesting review! I read about the first 100 pages of this book and just could not get into it. Maybe I’ll get back to it soon.