The Wives of Henry Oades – Book Review

The Wives of Henry Oades by Johanna Moran

When Henry Oades tells his wife, Meg, that they will be moving from London to New Zealand, she isn’t exactly thrilled about the prospect.  In the late 19th century, a trip from London to New Zealand could be quite the harrowing experience, and New Zealand did not have many of the creature comforts of London.  However, it was initially supposed to be only two years, so she agreed to take her son and daughter and go with him.  Of course their trip was not only two years long, and their family grew while in New Zealand by twin girls.  Then, one day, while Henry was at work, Meg, her children, their neighbor, and her son were set upon by Maori seeking revenge for the public punishment of one of their own.

When Henry returns to his house that night, he finds a woman’s body no longer recognizable.  The neighbor’s carriage is at his house, so he has no idea whether the body belongs to her or to his dear Meg.  Regardless, his wife and children are either dead or missing.  After a long period of mourning, Henry finally gives his family up for dead and decides to move to Berkeley, California, where he will not be so haunted by the memories of his family.  In Berkeley, Henry makes the acquaintance of a young girl left pregnant and widowed.  After the birth of her child, he marries her for what is love on his part, and protection on her part.  When Meg and her children show up one day on Henry and Nancy’s front porch, everything in all of their lives becomes infinitely more complicated – and they are indicted for bigamy.

This was a beautifully written book, based on real events.  All Moran had to work with was a scant document, she had to fill in the majority of the action herself, and she did a superb job. The thing that particularly struck me was how sympathetically the characters were written.  I really, really, really wanted to hate Nancy multiple times; for one thing she was essentially the other woman, although that was not her fault.  Much more obnoxious was her immaturity, she did not truly seem to want to be either wife or mother.  Since regaining her status as wife and mother was what Meg truly desired, it pained me to see Nancy in her place.  However, every time I got myself good and worked up to hate Nancy, Moran would show me her frailty and humanity and I would find it impossible to feel anything but sympathy for the predicament she found herself in.  I also appreciated that Moran presented the story of the Oades without moralizing, I have no idea whether she considered Nancy or Meg Henry’s true wife, or what she felt about their predicament.

Although there were perhaps a few elements of Nancy and Meg’s stories that could have been explored further, this was overall a completely lovely debut novel, a fresh and new work of historical fiction.  I will definitely be looking for more from Moran in the future.

Buy this book from:
A local independent bookstore via Indiebound

This review was done with a book received from the publisher via the LibraryThing Early Reviewer program.
* These links are all affiliate links. If you buy your book here I’ll make a very small amount of money that goes towards hosting, giveaways, etc.

Digiprove sealCopyright protected by Digiprove © 2010

15 comments to The Wives of Henry Oades – Book Review

  • Thanks for the great review – will definitely add this one to the list – love historical fiction.

  • The premise sounds intriguing. I will have to check this one out.

  • Kay

    I bought this book the other day at B&N after reading a review on another blog. The premise of this book interests me. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

  • Happy Blogiversary!!!!

    Oh yeah – the book . . . haven’t read it, sounds intriguing, might read it. More importantly

    Happy Blogiversary!!!!

  • I thought Nancy was pretty funny actually, but I have to admit I still feel like everyone got along just a little too fine. :) Maybe that shows how insecure I am!

    • Well, I think they partly got along because they didn’t know what else to do. Nancy was intimidated by the fact that Margaret had been married to Henry first, and had his children – plus Nancy wasn’t much of one for asserting herself. And Margaret got along because of her children, because she didn’t want to deny them their father after talking so much about how it would be for them to be back with him. I think some affection grew out of the basically forced civility, which I think is at least plausible.

    • I felt just a tad the same way, Amy. The way I eventually worked that out was that living with Nancy was better than living as a slave. Just being alive trumped the pain and disappointment.

  • I find this story fascinating! I don’t remember where I saw the review first, but is something I think I would like simply because it is so bizarre and a true story! It wouldn’t be nearly as appealing if it were completely fictional.

  • I love books that are inspired by true stories so this one sounds right up my alley. Great review!

  • I just finished this book last night and was simply blown away with it. I could not imagine living after those events. Nor could I imagine looking at what happened to the Oades as bigamy in the same way as what Mormons practiced at or just before that time. Great review, Jen!

  • Wow … this sounds intriguing on a lot of different levels. And to think it was based on a true story!!! I’m going to have to keep an eye out for this one.

  • As you know, I loved this one as well. The characters still haunt me! I’ll definitely be keeping an eye out for more from this author!

  • Very nice review. It sounds like a good book. I like fresh and new books.

  • I have read a few reviews of this and it sounds like a great read. I didn’t, however, realize that it was based on a true story. That just piqued y interest even more.

  • I was really skeptical about this book when I first heard about it, but now I’m hearing all this great stuff about it. I’m going to have to read it now!