The Boleyn Wife – Book Review

The Boleyn Wife by Brandy Purdy

“Another Tudor book?” you’re probably thinking, “I thought you had Tudor fatigue?”  Well, yes, I sort of do, but I agreed to review this book before I said that.  Plus, even though I have Tudor-fatigue, I still find it almost impossible to pass them by.  In fact, I just requested another one.  But I’m not just taking straight Tudor books anymore, they have to have an angle.  The one I just requested centers around Elizabeth’s governess, and “The Boleyn Wife” is told from the perspective of Jane Boleyn.

Jane loves her husband George Boleyn beyond all reason.  Unfortunately, the only woman he has eyes for is his sister Anne who is being courted by King Henry.  Most of you know the story from there: Henry changes the religion of England to divorce his wife and marry Anne, Anne fails to produce sons and gets on Henry’s nerves, Henry looks for a way to get rid of Anne and Jane provides him with testimony that sends Anne, George, and others to their deaths.  Three queens later, Jane helps Katherine Howard cuckold Henry with Thomas Culpepper and ends up in the Tower and on the block herself.

I have mixed feelings about this book.  On one hand, it kept me very engaged, especially considering it is the umpteenth book about the Tudors I’ve read.  On the other hand, there were certain things that really drew me out of the story.  At one point Mary Boleyn is exiled to Hever pregnant with Henry’s child, a few pages later she is back at court participating in a masque with Anne.  It wasn’t entirely clear how much time had passed, so it may have been that her exile had ended, but that wasn’t explained and confused for a moment.  It also surprised me that Jane Boleyn would describe Jane Seymour as ‘housewifely,’ but looking into it, ‘housewife’ has evidently been in use since the 13th century, so I suppose that is not anachronistic as it originally seemed to me.

I’d say I would have really enjoyed it overall, but there were a couple of things that really bothered me.  The repetition of the untrue rumor of Anne having a sixth finger is getting really old, and I wish novelists would stop repeating it.  Then there was Jane Boleyn having Thomas Cromwell’s child.  And Katherine Howard and Anne of Cleves as lovers.  Those last two things almost made me wish the book had ended with Anne and George’s deaths.

I’m really torn, “The Boleyn Wife” was well-written and engaging, but there were some crazy additions that out-Philippa Gregory’d Philippa Gregory that really bugged me.  If you don’t mind some pretty significant liberties taken with your historical fiction, then you’ll probably enjoy this book.

Buy this book from:
A local independent bookstore via Indiebound

This review was done with a book sent to me from the author.
* These links are all affiliate links. If you buy your book here I’ll make a very small amount of money that goes towards hosting, giveaways, etc.

Digiprove sealCopyright protected by Digiprove © 2010

10 comments to The Boleyn Wife – Book Review

  • I have been getting very burned out on historical fiction in general. Like you, I try to read stuff that has a bit of a twist–otherwise it starts seeming repetative.
    .-= Stephanie´s last blog ..East of Eden–part 1 =-.

  • “out Philippa Gregory’d Philippa Gregory” lol!!!

  • The Tudor period just hasn’t appealed to me at all. I’m sure I’d love the right Tudor book if I’d give it a try, but I have a feeling this isn’t the right one.

  • I can take a few liberties with my historical ficiton (say, Gregory shifting the birth order of the Boleyn girls) but illegitimate children and lesbian relationships? That’s probably taking it too far for me.

  • I’m really intrigued by the Tudor era, but there is only so much that can be written. I love Phillippa Gregory’s novels.

  • Like Kathy, this era never really appealed to me. I have friends that read everything they can get their hands on that is related to these characters though. I suppose some day, I just need to try one and see if I like it. I shall come to you and ask for your recommendation!
    .-= Sandy´s last blog ..When Teachers Talk – Rosalyn S. Schnall =-.

  • This book lost me at the Katherine Howard/Anne of Cleves lesbian love affair. Yeah, that’s going too far in my book, too. I think I’ll skip this one. I like Jane best out of the spotlight.
    .-= Literate Housewife´s last blog ..Where Has This Book Been My Whole Life? =-.

  • Sigh. I think I’ll pass this one by. Perhaps a little fanciful on the retelling of history. There are so many excellent Tudor books.
    .-= Beth F´s last blog ..Review: The Book of Fires by Jane Borodale =-.

  • Wisteria Leigh

    I have heard too many negatives on this one. I think I’ll skip it. Thanks for your review. You always make me chuckle with your humor. Thanks.

  • Book Bug

    Had to read book to the end but felt writers slant on certain characters too negative.
    It’s good to have a new slant on a story but I have never heard of a lesbian aspect to either Anne Of Cleves or Katherine Howard.
    Sexual Cromwell!!?
    I am far from being a prude but some of the story lines in this novel are just an excuse for pure gratuitous literary pornography. Not what you would expect from this genre.
    Try another historical novel. Plenty out there much better and historically accurate than this.